I think it's fair to say that most of the feedback regarding the Nady/Marte trade has been negative towards the return that the Pirates received. As I said over the weekend, I think that's misguided, considering the Bucs traded guys who had some short-term value for team-controlled guys with considerably more long-term value, among other reasons.
Well, it seems that I am not alone in that thinking, thankfully:
First, Peter Bendix of Behind the Box Score takes a look at Nady's production against right-handed pitching, which is up this year from his career averages, and concludes that it is unlikely that Xavier suddenly figured out how to hit righties at 29. To be fair, that's not what the Yankees wanted him for, and he still has value for his high numbers against lefties.
Secondly, the aforementiond Mr. Bendix gives a more general view of the Pirates' return on this trade, and has favorable things to say about the deal, namely:
Xavier Nady and Damaso Marte are luxuries, nice to have if you can afford them but certainly not core players. As such, they are unlikely to bring in any top flight talent along the lines of a Matt LaPorta. The Pirates are in the position where they need quantity almost as much as they need quality, and they received both in this deal. While none of the pitchers are likely to be as good as a Phil Hughes or even an Ian Kennedy, we are talking about three pitchers with an excellent chance of helping a major league roster in each of the next six years; not to mention the fact that McCutchen and Ohlendorf could prove to be above-league-average pieces. Furthermore, despite his problems this year, Jose Tabata is still only 19 years old and thus has plenty of time to figure it out (both on and off the field).
This article from, of all places, The New York Post, includes a telling quote from "an AL executive" (Mark Shapiro, perhaps?) who said the following:
"For Pittsburgh, it's not a great trade talent-wise, but I like what it represents...A lot rides on Tabata, who is a tool shed. Although there are concerns about his health, power and perhaps his makeup, he has the potential to be an impact player at a premium position by the time the Pirates should be competing again. Although not perfect because Ohlendorf is a middle man - maybe better in the NL - and the two other guys are long shots, it is precisely the type of deal the Pirates should be making: That is, one that exchanges impending free agents for potentially premier talent that is more suited to their time horizon. It is also the type of deal that the Pittsburgh club had not been making in recent years, despite it being in its best interest."
Lastly, Fan Graphs chimed in over the weekend with an entry that basically says the percentages point to 2008 Nady looking more like 2007 Nady in the second half of this season. Again, not that there's anything wrong with that.
This morning I actually read someone compare this trade to the Jason Schmidt and Aramis Ramirez deals, which is absolutely ridiculous. Those deals were (impending) salary dumps, where the Bucs got NOTHING in return, and this deal is nowhere close to that level of futility. To buy low on a high-risk, high-reward prospect and get three starting pitchers who can at least help the major league club in the very near future is at the very least decent return for a rental LOOGY and a guy who would be a platoon outfielder on any team other than the Pirates.
As you can tell, I'm frustrated by all this. The notion that the Pirates get screwed on these deals every year by the smarter, richer big market teams is blinding people from seeing that this actually was a good deal for the Bucs. It was a good deal for the Yankees too, but the MSM needs to declare a "winner" and a "loser" so Skip Bayless has something to freak out about on whatever they call Cold Pizza now.
Not that we ever really did, but can we get back to talking baseball and making use of common sense instead of overreacting to everything? It's apparently not likely.
1 hour ago
No comments:
Post a Comment